Excellent article on "when anti-Zionism becomes anti-semitism" in 
Shiraz Socialist.
“Absolute anti-Zionism” can be summed up as as a one-sided hostility to  Zionism (ie: Jewish nationalism) that willfully refuses to place it in  its proper historical context (the pogroms, persecution and genocide of  the last century), that whitewashes bourgeoise Arab nationalism and  reactionary, fascistic Islamism, applies double-standards to Israel and  ultimately winds up denying Israel’s right to exist, even behind  pre-1967 borders.... 
What needs to be spelled out plainly is that this sort of stuff is  anti-semitism, pure and simple. The fact that the people putting it  about regard themselves as “left wing” is neither here nor there. [Dan]  Glazebook (book reviewer for the Morning Star, the British newspaper of the Communist Party of Britain], significantly, also writes in what is probably the  world’s leading “left” anti-semitic publication, the US magazine Counterpunch.  In fact, the roots of this type of “left wing” anti-semitism are in  Stalinism and the Stalinist bureaucracy’s campaigns against “Zionism”  from the 1930′s through the 1952-3 “Doctors’ Plot” in the USSR and the ”anti-Zionist” campaign in Poland in 1967-68. 
In fact, given their political tradition’s foul history of promoting the “Socialism of fools“,  Mr Haylett and his Stalinist colleagues really aught to be more careful  about their pandering to ‘absolute anti-Zionism’: or, as it is more  properly called: “left wing” anti-semitism.
Good comment also: 
We could call it the anti-zionism of fools, but that sounds too mild, too much like the criticism of a few blameless ignorants. They aren’t blameless and they aren’t ignorant. They are racist scoundrels. And they have infected the left with a disease that should have died in 1945, certainly by March 5, 1953.
No comments:
Post a Comment